⭐ Five Stars — Masked Obsession, Unhinged Banter and a Surprisingly Adorable Stalker
Lights Out is the kind of book that feels like sneaking chocolate cake for breakfast: a little bit wicked, a lot of fun, and somehow exactly what you needed. Navessa Allen takes all the things you probably shouldn’t want in a romance—stalking, mask kink, questionable choices, and a dash of real danger—and somehow spins them into a story that’s not just laugh-out-loud funny, but surprisingly tender too. It’s the sort of dark romance that manages to be both a little bit wild and a little bit soft around the edges, and honestly, I loved every minute.
Josh is a masked thirst-trap creator with the kind of golden retriever energy that makes you wonder if someone left the internet unlocked just for him. Aly, on the other hand, is an exhausted trauma nurse whose daydreams are every bit as questionable as the man who’s determined to bring them to life. Put them together and you get the sort of delicious chaos that’s impossible to look away from—the kind that’s messy, addictive, and just a little bit wonderful.
📚 Book Details

Title: Lights Out
Author: Navessa Allen
Series: Into Darkness – Book 1 of 3
Format Read: eBook and Audiobook
Genre: Dark Romance / Romantic Suspense
Publication Date: June 6, 2023
My Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Spice Rating: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Read Type: First Read
Content Note: This dark romance contains stalking, violence, murder, trauma, home invasion, consensual non-consent, fear play, knife play, breath play, blood play and other intense sexual content.
→ View the full content-warning list here.
This book explores fantasies and situations that would be frightening, harmful and illegal outside the fictional, consensual dynamic created between the characters. Protect your mental health and never rely on a shortened warning list alone.
I originally read this book through my Kindle Unlimited subscription alongside the audiobook—and, obviously, loved it enough to buy my own physical copy. All opinions—and my sudden understanding of the mask-kink community—are entirely my own.
✨ At a Glance
Tropes: Masked Man • Stalker Romance • Morally Grey MMC • Obsessive Hero • Touch Her and Die • Trauma Nurse FMC • Cat and Mouse • Forced Proximity
Vibes: Dark Romance Chaos • Masked Thirst Traps • Unhinged Banter • Criminally Questionable Flirting • Unexpected Softness
Romance: An overworked trauma nurse catches the attention of the masked creator starring in her darkest fantasies
Hero Status: Tattooed internet menace with golden-retriever energy and absolutely no respect for privacy laws
Biggest Strength: The perfect balance between darkness, comedy, romance and suspense
Main Weakness: My standards may now include “masked stalker who brings snacks”
Favourite Element: Josh being simultaneously terrifying, hilarious and ridiculously devoted
Audiobook Highlight: Jacob Morgan sounding like a darker, sexier and even more unhinged Deadpool
Duet Narration: Yes—and thank goodness for that
Would I Reread It? Absolutely, preferably with the audiobook turned all the way up
Most Accurate Reaction: This is deeply questionable…please continue immediately
💭 The Quick Take
Lights Out is the kind of book that sneaks up on you and settles in for a while. It’s got all the shadows and spice you could want, but never loses sight of the feelings underneath. I found myself laughing out loud one minute and holding my breath the next, which is honestly my favorite kind of reading experience. What really stuck with me, though, was the way Josh and Aly just spark off each other—there’s this wild, messy chemistry between them that somehow feels both sharp and unexpectedly tender. The mask kink and the suspenseful twists might be what first catch your eye, but it’s the softness threaded through the darkness, and the way the duet audiobook brings every moment to life, that make it linger long after you’ve finished.
Is it bold? Absolutely. A little bit unhinged? Oh, for sure. But somehow, every wild, over-the-top moment just fits. It’s the kind of book that shouldn’t work, but does—and I loved every second of it.
📖 Story Snapshot — Spoiler Free
Aly Cappellucci is a trauma nurse who’s been getting by on a steady diet of exhaustion, dark humour, and a handful of daydreams she’d never actually admit to anyone. But then she stumbles across a masked creator online, and suddenly, the edges of her world start to blur in the most unexpected ways.
Josh Hammond is a master at keeping his identity tucked away, and his videos—equal parts unsettling and magnetic—give Aly’s imagination more than enough fuel. She’s convinced her curiosity will stay safely on her side of the screen, until a twist of fate (and a mutual friend) lands her right in Josh’s path. Suddenly, the line between fantasy and reality isn’t quite so clear. When Josh realises Aly is drawn to his masked persona, he finds himself just as intrigued by the woman behind the screen. What starts as fascination soon turns into something much deeper—and a little bit dangerous.
What starts as a risky little game between a masked man and the woman who once only imagined being chased quickly turns into something neither of them saw coming. As Josh and Aly wander deeper into the shadows of their own desires, a real-world threat edges closer, uninvited. The game they’re playing is all about choice. The danger waiting just outside? Not so much.
📚 My Reading Experience
🤯 The Book That Completely Blew My Mind
Lights Out is one of those rare finds that feels like it shouldn’t work, but somehow it just does. I went in expecting all the darkness and spice (and yes, the mask), but I didn’t expect to be snorting with laughter in between all the tension. Navessa Allen has this way of weaving together dark romance, suspense, kink, and the kind of humour that makes you question if you should really be laughing right now. One minute I was holding my breath, the next I was blushing, and then Josh would drop a line so ridiculous I had to pause and just grin at the page. It’s a wild mix, but it never feels jarring. That kind of balance is honestly magic.
It’s such a tricky thing, getting the mix just right. Too many jokes and the shadows lose their bite. Too much darkness and the romance gets lost. Too much heat and suddenly the characters feel like afterthoughts. But here, it all fits together in this perfectly tangled way: the tension makes the intimacy feel earned, the humour lets you see who these people really are, the spice is all about trust, and the suspense keeps you guessing what Josh and Aly actually mean to each other. That’s the real magic for me. I was completely swept up from the first page and honestly, I’m still thinking about it.
🎭 The Mask Isn’t Just There to Look Pretty
Although, let’s be honest, it definitely doesn’t hurt. At first glance, the mask kink feels like that splashy detail meant to catch your eye. And yes, it does exactly that. But as the story unfolds, the mask starts to mean something more. It quietly settles in, becoming part of the atmosphere and the feelings that grow between the characters.
For Aly, the mask is a gentle buffer between what’s real and what’s just for play. It gives her space to dip her toes into fear, surrender, and all those fluttery feelings, while still knowing she’s safe in the make-believe. For Josh, the mask is a little like a secret identity. He gets to step into the role people crave online, all while keeping his true self tucked away. Somewhere along the way, their separate daydreams start to blend together.
When those daydreams finally meet, the mask turns into something a little magical. It’s a symbol of risk, but also of comfort. It hides things, but it also gives them both permission to share the parts of themselves they usually keep tucked away. So yes, it’s not just there to make things spicy, though it absolutely does that too. Sometimes, the things that look the most daring end up being the ones that make us feel safest.
😂 Dark Romance Has Never Been This Funny
The humour is honestly what tipped this one into five-star territory for me. Josh and Aly aren’t just brooding in the shadows, lost in their own drama. They’re quick-witted, a little odd in the best way, and somehow manage to crack jokes at exactly the wrong (or maybe right?) moments. Their conversations feel like the kind you overhear and wish you could join in on—effortless and just the right amount of cheeky. Josh, especially, is a handful. He’s got this unpredictable streak that keeps you on your toes, but also the kind of energy where you half-expect him to break into your house and then complain about your choice of throw pillows.
There were so many moments where I found myself going from oh no to oh yes to wait, what just happened, and then right back again. That kind of emotional rollercoaster is exactly what makes this book such a delight. I didn’t just sign up for the ride—I’d happily queue up for another go.
📈 A Plot That Never Lets You Breathe
This is one of those stories that grabs your hand from the very first page and doesn’t really let go. Just when you think you can catch your breath, something new pulls you right back in. It’s not just a string of spicy moments with a plot tacked on for good measure. There’s a real sense of danger simmering underneath, and the suspense keeps building in a way that makes you want to peek ahead (but you won’t, because you’re good). The world feels bigger than what’s on the page, with hints of more secrets and trouble waiting in the wings for the rest of the series.
The suspense isn’t just there for the thrills, either. It gives Josh’s protective streak a real sense of purpose, something deeper than just a few possessive lines of dialogue. When things get serious, he’s all in—no hesitation, just pure, messy devotion. You might raise an eyebrow at some of his choices, but you never doubt where his heart is.
✍️ Navessa Allen Understood the Assignment
Navessa Allen’s writing has this deliciously dark edge, but it’s the kind you can sink into without feeling overwhelmed. The suspense rolls in at just the right moments, and when the emotions hit, they’re given room to breathe. The humour bubbles up through the characters in a way that feels effortless, never forced. And the banter? It’s sharp and clever, with just enough bite to keep you on your toes. Somehow, all of this makes a premise that should feel wild and impossible seem like the most natural thing in the world.
There’s a lovely self-awareness woven through the writing, the kind that makes you feel like you’re in on the secret. The story knows it’s a little wild, and instead of shying away, it leans right in and lets the characters shine with real, honest emotion. It never tries to be anything it’s not, and that quiet confidence is what makes the whole thing sing. By the end, it’s that sense of assurance that lingers most.
💘 Character Corner
Favourite Character: Josh
Most Compelling Character: Josh
My Fictional Crush: Joshua Hammond, mask included
Character Who Surprised Me Most: Josh—because underneath the stalking, hacking and criminal behaviour is one giant chaotic softie
Character I Wanted to Protect: Aly
Favourite Dynamic: Aly fantasising about danger while Josh becomes determined to provide it—with consent, preparation and apparently no chill whatsoever
Biggest Red Flag: The stalking. Obviously. We are not pretending otherwise.
Most Accurate Josh Description: A golden retriever wearing a wolf mask and carrying several cybercrime charges
Most Accurate Aly Description: An exhausted trauma nurse who discovers that her darkest fantasy has excellent comedic timing
🩺 Aly Cappellucci — Exhausted, Sharp and Stronger Than She Knows
Aly spends her days (and far too many nights) as a trauma nurse, holding it together for everyone else when the world feels like it’s falling apart. She’s clever, capable, and has a sense of humour that could probably cut through steel, but she’s also the kind of person who quietly puts herself at the bottom of her own list. Underneath all that confidence and those dark, twisty daydreams, there’s a woman carrying more than she ever really says out loud. Aly’s fascination with fear and masked men isn’t about being powerless. She knows what she wants, and when Josh steps out of her imagination and into her real life, she doesn’t just go along for the ride. She sets her own boundaries, pushes back when she needs to, and decides for herself how far she’ll let things go. She’s braver than she thinks.
There’s something quietly powerful about seeing someone finally step up to protect the woman who’s always been the one holding everyone else together. It gets me every time.
🎭 Josh Hammond: Golden Retriever in a Wolf Mask
Josh is a bit of a beautiful mess: he’s the kind of masked mystery who probably shouldn’t be as charming as he is, but somehow, he pulls it off. He’s got this wild streak, always circling Aly, breaking a few rules here and there, but then he’ll turn around and make you laugh or cling a little too close, just to remind you he’s still human underneath it all. He can be scary, I won’t lie, but there’s something about his sense of humour and those flashes of vulnerability that make his obsession feel real and strangely tender.
It’s not just about wanting Aly for Josh. He wants to know her, make her laugh, keep her safe, and maybe even be the one she trusts with the dreams she’s never dared to share. That little dance between being a bit dangerous and then suddenly soft is exactly what makes him so fascinating. One minute, he’s looming in the shadows with his mask on, and the next, he’s all but wagging his tail just because Aly looked his way. Golden retriever in a wolf mask really does say it all.
🔥 Chemistry, Romance & Spice
🖤 The Romance
Josh and Aly’s story kicks off in a way that would make any etiquette book clutch its pearls—think peeking, daydreaming, and a courtship style that’s more eyebrow-raising than candlelit dinner. Would I call it romantic if it happened down the street? Not a chance. But in the safe little bubble of fiction, there’s something about their spark that just sweeps you up before you even know what’s happening.
Their chemistry is the kind that lights up the room right away, but the real magic is how slowly and gently the trust grows between them. Josh doesn’t flinch at Aly’s shadows, and Aly looks past Josh’s bravado to see the softer, more uncertain parts he usually keeps hidden. There’s something so comforting about watching two people let themselves be truly seen. Their banter is the heartbeat of it all, their quirks and kinks nudge them into honest conversations, and as things get riskier, you can feel just how much they’ve come to mean to each other.
Their whole dynamic is a little bit wild and a little bit wonderful—fear and longing tangled up until you can’t quite tell where one ends and the other begins. What starts as obsession quietly turns into something real, and all that emotional messiness somehow settles into a connection that just feels right. There’s banter that makes you laugh out loud, a tough guy who melts into absolute mush for his person, and a pair who fit together so well it almost feels like a secret only they (and maybe us, peeking in) get to share. It’s a beautiful kind of chaos.
🌶️ The Spice
Let’s be honest, the spice is a big part of the draw here, and this book does not hold back. There’s a whole spectrum of kink woven through Josh and Aly’s story—mask play, fear play, knife play, breath play, and consensual non-consent all make an appearance. What really stood out to me, though, was how thoughtful it all felt. The heat isn’t just there for shock or spectacle; it grows out of their shared fantasies, their honest conversations, and the trust they build together. Even when things get dark or a little scary, Aly’s pleasure and her enthusiastic consent are always at the heart of it all.
The mask scenes, in particular, are something special. There’s a real edge to the fantasy, but what lingers is the sense of connection underneath it all. Josh is so attuned to Aly—he notices every little shift, every reaction, and makes sure she feels safe enough to let go completely. It’s intense, yes, but also surprisingly tender.
Frequency: Very high. Detail: extremely explicit. Kink level: intense. Overall spice rating: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️. This book didn’t simply turn up the heat—it removed the thermostat, threw it through a window, and arrived wearing a mask.
🎧 Audiobook Notes
Narrators: Elena Wolfe and Jacob Morgan
Narration Style: Duet
This audiobook feels like a treat I didn’t know I needed. The duet narration is what really makes it shine.
Jacob Morgan just gets it. His take on Josh has that wild, unpredictable spark—think Deadpool if he wandered into a darker, more seductive story and decided to stay a while. One minute he’s tossing out a snarky line, the next he’s got this edge that makes you sit up a little straighter, and then suddenly there’s a softness that sneaks in and catches you off guard. The timing is spot on, so Josh never tips too far into villain or cartoon territory. The jokes actually make me laugh, the possessive streak feels intense in all the right ways, and every now and then you catch a glimpse of the lonely guy underneath it all.
Elena Wolfe gives Aly so much life, too. You can hear every bit of Aly’s tiredness, sharp wit, and that quiet strength that never quite hides how much she feels. And honestly, the duet narration is the real magic trick here. Each narrator sticks to their own character’s lines, so there’s none of that awkward voice-hopping that usually yanks me out of the story. Instead, their voices weave together so naturally that the conversations feel like you’re right there with them. After so many audiobooks with alternating narrators trying (and sometimes failing) to mimic each other, this feels like the cozy, immersive experience I’ve been hoping for. No odd voices, just two brilliant performances that make the whole thing feel real.
💬 A Line I Had to Save
“I didn’t want him morally grey. I wanted someone with a soul as black as night. Someone who would burn the world down for me and not lose a single minute of sleep over it.”
✨ The Bookish Extras
📸 Meet Josh and Aly

My imagined version of Josh and Aly, created using AI from their character descriptions in the book.
🎵 The Soundtrack
Masked obsession, dangerous attraction, dark fantasies, completely inappropriate humour and the musical equivalent of realising the man breaking into your home might also be your soulmate.
📌 Enter Josh and Aly’s World
Black masks, blue roses, shadowy bedrooms, blood-red lighting, tattooed hands, exhausted night shifts, dangerous text messages and enough dark-romance energy to make every sensible instinct quietly leave the room.
💌 You’ll Love This If…
You may enjoy Lights Out if you love:
- Dark romance with genuine humour
- Masked men
- Stalker romance
- Morally grey heroes
- Obsessive and possessive MMCs
- Touch-her-and-die energy
- Golden-retriever men with criminal tendencies
- Strong heroines with dark fantasies
- Cat-and-mouse dynamics
- Fear play and consensual non-consent
- Extremely explicit spice
- Sharp, chaotic banter
- Romantic suspense
- Genuine external danger
- Emotionally meaningful kink
- Dual points of view
- Duet audiobook narration
- Heroes who are dangerous to everyone except her
- Relationships built around trust and communication
- Standalone romances within an interconnected series
You May Want to Skip It If…
This may not be for you if:
- Stalking is a hard limit
- Home invasion is difficult for you to read
- You dislike morally questionable romantic leads
- Mask or fear play makes you uncomfortable
- Consensual non-consent is a hard limit
- Knife, breath or blood play isn’t within your comfort zone
- You prefer low-spice or closed-door romance
- On-page violence or murder is upsetting
- Dark humour during serious situations doesn’t work for you
- You need completely realistic or healthy courtship
- Possessive heroes frustrate you
- You prefer gentle romance without suspense
- Extremely explicit sexual content isn’t for you
My verdict: Read every content warning first. If the darker themes fall within your comfort zone, prepare for one of the funniest, filthiest and most unexpectedly tender stalker romances imaginable.
⭐ The Final Chapter
Would I Recommend It? Absolutely—to established dark-romance readers who check their content warnings
Would I Reread It? Without hesitation
Would I Read More From the Author? Already reaching for the next book
Would I Continue the Series? Absolutely
Did the Ending Satisfy Me? Yes
Favourite Character: Josh
Most Compelling Character: Josh
Favourite Element: The contrast between Josh’s dangerous masked persona and chaotic golden-retriever personality
Biggest Strength: The seamless blend of darkness, humour, suspense, romance and spice
Main Weakness: It may have permanently raised my audiobook expectations
Best Format: eBook alongside the audiobook
Audiobook MVP: Jacob Morgan as Josh
Audiobook Powerhouse: Elena Wolfe’s humour and emotional delivery as Aly
Audiobook Highlight: Proper duet narration
Most Accurate Summary: An exhausted trauma nurse thirsts over a masked creator and accidentally attracts the world’s most devoted cyber-stalking golden retriever
Book Hangover Level: Currently side-eyeing every masked thirst trap on the internet
Shelf Keeper? I need the physical copy immediately
Overall Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
🖤 Final Thoughts + Come Chat
Lights Out is bold, different, and completely unforgettable. It made me laugh, gasp, question my fictional taste in men, and completely lose track of time. The story is chaotic, emotional, intense, and outrageously spicy—yet somehow, it’s also incredibly fun.
Josh and Aly work because neither needs the other to pretend. Aly doesn’t have to hide the fantasies she fears other people might judge, and Josh doesn’t have to remain trapped behind the dangerous persona he shows online. They recognise each other’s darkness, but they also uncover the humour, vulnerability, and loneliness hidden underneath.
The stalking might begin the story. The mask might sell the fantasy. The spice might set the pages on fire. But their emotional connection is what earns the five stars.
Josh’s obsession develops into fierce devotion without losing the unhinged energy that makes him so entertaining. Aly remains strong and self-aware while finally allowing someone else to protect her. Their banter gives the darkness room to breathe, while the suspense proves that the story has far more to offer than an attractive man in a mask.
Although…
The attractive man in the mask certainly didn’t hurt.
And that audiobook?
Jacob Morgan and Elena Wolfe delivered everything. The duet format made each conversation feel natural, immersive, and wonderfully alive. Jacob’s darker-Deadpool energy suited Josh perfectly, while Elena captured every layer of Aly’s exhaustion, humour, and emotional strength. This wasn’t simply a five-star read—it was the kind of book that makes you immediately understand the obsession surrounding it.
Have you read Lights Out?
Did Josh’s stalking send you running for the police—or did his golden-retriever energy make the red flags look suspiciously decorative?
And be honest…did this book awaken the mask kink, or was it already waiting patiently in the darkness? 👀🎭
Come chat with me in the comments—but please keep things spoiler-free for anyone who hasn’t met Josh and Aly yet!








Leave a comment